Clarity for AI buildersSponsored by AI Routing
policy

EU Digital ID Wallets Can Limit What You Share but Still Leave You Trackable

EU Digital ID Wallets Can Limit What You Share but Still Leave You Trackable

EU digital ID wallets can limit what users disclose, but their cryptographic records could still link users across services.

As EU member states prepare to roll out their wallets by year’s end, IEEE Spectrum reports that the European Commission has not made zero-knowledge proofs mandatory for the initial rollout. The EU regulation requires both selective disclosure and unlinkability, but it does not prescribe a cryptographic protocol. The distinction matters: a wallet can tell a bar that a customer is over 18 without revealing a name or address, yet still expose a signature or identifier that lets two businesses recognize that they checked the same credential.

Issuing several versions of a credential would reduce that risk by letting a wallet present a different version each time. But that shifts some of the privacy burden to the issuer rather than removing it, Anna Lysyanskaya, a computer science professor at Brown University, told IEEE Spectrum. If the issuer can trace the different versions back to the same person, it could help verifiers connect records that they could not match on their own.

Zero-knowledge proofs offer a different approach: the wallet can prove a credential is valid without handing over the signature that would otherwise serve as a matching record. A verifier can still check that the credential is authentic, unchanged, unexpired and not revoked. IEEE Spectrum reports that shortly after the regulation passed in 2024, Google researchers found a way to generate such proofs for credentials signed with the elliptic curve digital signature algorithm, efficiently enough for use in a digital wallet.

The Commission says there is no agreed, certifiable EU-wide approach yet and has put zero-knowledge proofs on its roadmap. Individual countries can implement them, but Jaap-Henk Hoepman, an associate professor at Radboud University, warned that a service could ask for traditional verification instead. In practice, that means a wallet could support a more private option without users being able to rely on it at every service.

Johannes Schönrich of the FIM Research Center for Information Management told IEEE Spectrum that the EU should proceed with the rollout and use lessons from deployment to inform a second version, with a binding timetable for introducing zero-knowledge proofs. Hoepman warned that providers may be reluctant to pay for a later migration, while Lysyanskaya said some users may never update unless required to do so.

The choice is therefore not just whether the first wallets improve on showing a full ID, but whether the verification methods adopted at launch will be easy to replace.